By: George Orwell
This book is obviously about dystopia on a huge scale. The whole world is broken. If the "inner party" doesn't think you are broken enough, they will see to it that you are broken further.
Other than making me want to jump out of my arm chair and take up residence in the nearest cave, "1984" brought many questions to mind.
Is this book easy for a person not suffering huge scale tragedy to relate to?
My answer is yes. It took me a while, but I started seeing how much broken people are alike. Some people may be broken by "Big Brother" and the "inner party". Some people may have been broken by something seemingly smaller, such as constant abuse and fear of a family member "Big Brother". In the end the person is still just a shell of what they once were.The abused child will grow up broken and end up wanting to rewrite the past. This isn't possible on a small scale so they will end up "doublethinking" the situation. They can believe that they are loved yet abused. They fear that they will be left behind and become an "unperson" to their family if they say anything. In either of these situations and countless others a person feels isolated and fearful for their own life and safety.
If one knew that one was going to die within a short matter of time, how would it best be dealt with? Julia and Winston deal with their impending imprisonment and death differently.
Winston worries all the time, and tries to protect himself as much as possible. Julia is written as an immature yet insightful and cunning when it comes to certain subjects. Julia seems to brush off the fact that they will be caught and probably tortured and killed. She lives day to day and seeks as much joy as possible.
Neither way of dealing with this situation makes it any different in the end.
When reading Orwell's 1984, I disliked almost every character. I am not sure if this is intentional. These people have been reduced to doing horrible things.
Winston contemplates murdering Julia with a rock, only to find out she is not a member of the thought police and instantly falls in love with her. He can seemingly go from love to hate in a matter of minutes.
Julia seems entirely uninterested in anything that doesn't directly relate to her. This is a common trait amongst young people, but it is striking here because of how important I would think these things would be.
O'Brien is a hard character for me to analyze. I am never sure how much of what he is saying he actually believes. "Doublethink" is very important to his character. It's odd that Winston after the torture still loves O'Brien and see's him as someone he can talk to, whether he is friend or enemy.
Orwell did not have a very high opinion of the working class or the poor. That is pretty clear in how he treats them in the novel. Most of the minor characters who are not educated are shown are not liked by Winston the protagonist.
This book is about politics, but I think it can be about human suffering on any level as well. It's about many things beneath the surface. I think that is why it is still and will continue to be a book people will want to read.
I think this book is important in many ways, but it is very bleak. I am hoping for something a little more hopeful for my next blog.
No comments:
Post a Comment